C'mon, Can't This Be Handled Within The School?

I recently received a call from a parent who wanted to hire me to handle her son's juvenile case.  The young man (let's call him Dwight Schrute, as I am watching The Office right now) is being charged with criminal trespass.  Evidently, Dwight was suspended from school and the school has a policy requiring the parents of suspended students to meet with the vice-principal on the student's first day back from suspension to discuss the conditions of the student's continued enrollment.  Well, in this case, Dwight's mom (Mrs. Schrute) did not go to school with Dwight to meet the vice-principal on Dwight's first day back from suspension.  She put Dwight on the bus and he went to school like he normally does.  Dwight went through the entire school day without incident.  Just before Dwight's last class of the day, the vice-principal sees Dwight in the hallway and asks him why he's at school without his mother.  Dwight responds that his mother went to work and couldn't make it.  The vice-principal tells Dwight that he's not allowed back on campus until his mother has attended the required meeting.  The vice-principal then calls campus police and has Dwight arrested for criminal trespass.  This occurs less than one hour before the end of the school day.

Dwight now has a court date and is going to miss another day of school.  He now has a prosecutor who wants to convict him of a Class B Misdemeanor.  He now has a probation officer assigned to his case who is asking for 9 months of probation.  He now has to get a lawyer (through hire or appointment) to protect his rights.  

Can we quit putting these kids into the system for these kinds of things?!?  

Let's Me Get This Straight, My Kid is a Felon...?

As I've developed my criminal practice, one of the most rewarding aspects of my practice is juvenile defense. Why is it so rewarding? In my opinion, many of our courts are overzealous when it comes to juveniles. I know that the probation officers, prosecutors, and judges mean well and feel as if they are teaching a juvenile a lesson by being strict, but when kids are getting tagged as felons for tagging, the system is indeed overzealous.

If I can keep a juvenile from being labeled a felon or being put on probation over some mistake they've made, I feel like I've given that kid a second chance. I'm not saying we shouldn't hold kids responsible for their actions and I'm not saying that serious offenses don't warrant intervention and punishment from the state. My concern is that we are bringing kids into the criminal justice system for things that were previously handled within the home or within the school. I worry about the effect of getting so many kids into the system at such young ages.

Fighting at school is a good example. When I was growing up, if you got into a fight at school, you got detention (at school, not at a juvenile facility) or maybe, suspension. Now, thirteen year-old kids are taken into police custody and end up in court. As a result of their dispositions in court, many of the kids will end up on probation, with a probation officer checking in on them every so often. All of this for a fight at school.

The other problem that I have with the juvenile system is that in many of the cases that I see, it is the parents that should receive punishment, and not the kid. I've seen parents who know their kid is smoking marijuana is his room and yet, the parents do nothing. I've seen kids in court for violations of conditions of probation (curfew is a common one) and it was the parents that allowed the juvenile to violate the condition. Who gets punished? Not the parent who allowed Timmy to walk the streets at 11:00 pm with his friends. It's Timmy, for not being able to refrain from doing something his parents said was OK.

I once had a young girl (14 years-old or so) who was on probation for Possession of Marijuana and she had violated the conditions of her probation. As part of her probation, she had a curfew and a no contact order with her boyfriend. She would consistently violate both conditions. Her boyfriend was 19 and when she violated the conditions of probation, it was because this 19 year-old man would come over and take her out at all times of the night. She would sneak out of her window, act like she was staying at a friend's house, etc.

My problem with the case was - how can you punish a minor for being preyed upon by an adult? Basically, the state kept giving my client harsher and harsher punishment because she kept seeing this man. When I got her as a court appointed client and reviewed the file, I felt as if I was on crazy pills. Was I missing something? Who was the real criminal in all of this and who really deserved the punishment? My argument was that the state was essentially punishing her because she was being unduly influenced by an adult and that the state was holding her responsible for the actions of her adult boyfriend. After all, she's a minor. Can we expect her to refuse the callings of an adult who claims he loves and cares about her? My argument fell on deaf ears in court and once again, she had her probation modified.

I look back on her case and regret that I didn't do more for her. To this day, I truly believe she was a victim, not a criminal. And I failed her.